A list detailing all our previous discussions on whether a character qualifies as a Guile Hero.
March 2025
- Abra Stone from Silk: Shards of the Past - March 10, 2025 - Status: Ongoing
February 2025
- Sean Devlin from The Saboteur Proposal - February 28, 2025 - Status: Ongoing
- Jason Todd (Earth-998123) from Son of Red Hood Proposal - February 23, 2025 - Status: Approved
December 2024
- Sailor Mercury from Sailor Moon Proposal - December 24, 2024 - Status: Approved
- Prowler from Gold Bolt Proposal - December 15, 2024 - Status: Rejected
November 2024
- Silas Greaves from Call of Juarez: Gunslinger Proposal - November 23 - Status: Approved
- Nancy Thompson from A Nightmare on Elm Street Proposal - November 2 - Status: Approved
October 2024
- Dr. Samuel Loomis from Halloween (Original Continuity) Proposal - October 31 - Status: Approved
- Rigby from Regular Show Removal - October 16 - Status: Approved
- Terence from Angry Birds Proposal - October 6 - Status: Approved
August 2024
- Gromit from Wallace and Gromit Proposal - August 17 - Status: Approved
June 2024
- Ron Stallworth from BlacKkKlansman Proposal - June 25 - Status: Approved
April 2024
- Hermione Granger from Harry Potter Proposal - April 22 - Status: Approved
- Betty Barrett from Atomic Betty Proposal - April 8 - Status: Approved
- Lieutenant Columbo from Cheesypickles564's Columbo vs Light Yagami Proposal - April 3 - Status: Undetermined
- Doc and Marty from Back to the Future Proposal - April 1 - Status: Approved
March 2024
- Princess Elizabeth from The Paper Bag Princess Proposal - March 13 - Status: Approved
- Tommy Gilligan from Codename: Kids Next Door Proposal - March 13 - Status: Approved
- Tom and Jerry from Tom and Jerry Proposal - March 11 - Status: Approved
- The Man With No Name from The Dollar Trilogy Proposal - March 5 - Status: Approved
February 2024
- Minato Namikaze from Naruto Proposal - February 27 - Status: Approved
- Shikamaru Nara from Naruto Proposal - February 27 - Status: Approved
- Edge from Mario + Rabbids Proposal - February 4 - Status: Approved
January 2024
- Joseph Joestar from JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Proposal - January 22 - Status: Approved
- David from YTP Christmas Special: Psycho Boogie's Back! Proposal - January 11 - Status: Approved
- Patrick Jane from The Mentalist Proposal - January 2 - Status: Approved
December 2023
- Rayman from Rayman: The Animated Series Proposal - December 2 - Status: Approved
- Dot from Pokémon Horizons: The Series Proposal - December 1 - Status: Approved
November 2023
- The Doctor from Lego Dimensions Proposal - November 30 - Status: Approved
- Owen Grady from Jurassic Park - November 14 - Status: Approved
October 2023
- Doc Louis from Abobo's Big Adventure - October 28 - Status: Approved
- Plungerman from Skibidi Toilet Removal - October 21 - Status: Approved
- Danny Cat from Cats Don't Dance - October 16 - Status: Approved
- Jonathan Joestar from JoJo's Bizarre Adventure - October 13 - Status: Approved
- Mitsunari Ishida from Saihai no Yukue - October 9 - Status: Approved
- Olenna Tyrell from Game of Thrones - October 7 - Status: Approved
- Mia Fey from Ace Attorney - October 6 - Status: Approved
- Max Keeble from Max Keeble's Big Move - October 5 - Status: Approved
- Discord from DEATH BATTLE! - October 1 - Status: Approved
September 2023
- D. B. Cooper from Elsewhere - September 30 - Status: Approved
- Jesse Pinkman from Breaking Bad - September 14 - Status: Approved
- Ciel from Mega Man Zero - September 14 - Status: Approved
- Maddie from Back to the Outback - September 10 - Status: Approved
- Dr. Light from Mega Man - September 10 - Status: Approved
- Apple Kid from EarthBound - September 8 - Status: Approved
August 2023
- Wolverine from X-Men (Film Series) - August 31 - Status: Undetermined
- Flik from A Bug's Life - August 31 - Status: Approved
- Sidney Prescott from Scream - August 28 - Status: Approved
- Kuon Ichinose from Persona 5 Strikers - August 27 - Status: Approved
- Tari from SMG4 - August 27 - Status: Approved
- Professor E. Gadd from Super Mario Bros. Z - August 26 - Status: Approved
- Bryant from As Good as Dead - August 17 - Status: Approved
- Hank Schrader from Breaking Bad - August 16 - Status: Approved
- Nacho Varga from Better Call Saul - August 15 - Status: Approved
- Double Plunger Cameraman from Skibidi Toilet - August 8 - Status: Approved
July 2023
- Luz Noceda from The Owl House - July 5 - Status: Approved
June 2023
- Dr. Andonuts from EarthBound - June 27 - Status: Approved
- Aviva Corcovado from Wild Kratts - June 23 - Status: Approved
- Celestia Ludenberg from Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc - June 23 - Status: Approved
- Sasha Nein from Psychonauts - June 14 - Status: Approved
- Jenny Wakeman from My Life as a Teenage Robot - June 11 - Status: Approved
- Marcy Wu from Amphibia - June 3 - Status: Approved
- The Guru from Sly Cooper - June 1 - Status: Approved
- E.M. Pino and Holy from Edens Zero - June 1 - Status: Approved
- Weisz Steiner (X442), Witch Regret, Hermit Mio, Laguna Husert from Edens Zero - June 1 - Status: Approved
May 2023
- Max from Camp Camp - May 20 - Status: Approved
- John Connor from Terminator 2: Judgment Day - May 12 - Status: Approved
- Yushiro from Demon Slayer - May 7 - Status: Approved
- Mello from Death Note (Anime) - May 5 - Status: Approved
April 2023
- Kurisu Makise and Rintaro Okabe from Steins;Gate - April 30 - Status: Approved
- Jaycie and Kittie from The Legend of Team Brunette - April 26 - Status: Approved
- Joebotnik McCricket from Joe Venture - April 19 - Status: Approved
- Flint Lockwood from Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs - April 17 - Status: Approved
- Sarah Connor from The Terminator - April 7 - Status: Approved
- T-850 from Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines - April 5 - Status: Approved
- Clementine from The Walking Dead - April 2 - Status: Approved
- Pops, Kyle Reese, and Sarah Connor from Terminator Genisys - April 1 - Status: Approved
March 2023
- Urbosa from The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - March 28 - Status: Approved
- T-800 from Terminator 2: Judgement Day Proposal - March 26 - Status: Approved
- Kuon Ichinose from Persona 5 Strikers Proposal - March 10 - Status: Undetermined
- Meggy Spletzer from SMG4 Proposal - March 10 - Status: Approved
February 2023
- Kyle Reese from The Terminator Proposal - February 28 - Status: Approved
- Clover the Clever from My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Proposal - February 28 - Status: Approved
- Professor Huh? from Be Cool, Scooby-Doo! Proposal - February 12 - Status: Approved
- Willy Wonka from Charlie and the Chocolate Factory (books) Proposal - February 6 - Status: Approved
January 2023
- Fantastic Mr. Fox from The Fantastic Mr. Fox book Proposal - January 22 - Status: Approved
- Digory Kirke from The Chronicles of Narnia Proposal - January 22 - Status: Approved
- Buer from Genshin Impact Proposal - January 6 - Status: Approved
- Arisu Ryohei from Alice in Borderland Proposal - January 5 - Status: Approved
December 2022
- Purah and Robbie from The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - December 31 - Status: Approved
- EVE from WALL-E - December 30 - Status: Approved
- Knuckles the Dread and Nine from Sonic Prime - December 29 - Status: Approved
- Beetie Latier from Hunger Games - December 25 - Status: Approved
- Myles Fowl from Artemis Fowl - December 21 - Status: Approved
- Rue from Hunger Games - December 18 - Status: Approved
- Blossom and Brunette from Sonic and the Powerpuff Girls Proposal - December 11 - Status: Approved
- Jimmy Hopkins from Bully Proposal - December 10 - Status: Rejected
- Bentley from Sly Cooper Proposal - December 1 - Status: Approved
November 2022
- Sherazade from Sherazade: The Untold Stories Proposal - November 30 - Status: Approved
- Twilight Sparkle from My Little Pony: Equestria Girls Proposal - November 19 - Status: Approved
- Alhaitham and Taj Radkani from Genshin Impact Proposal - November 19 - Status: Approved
- Katniss Everdeen and Peeta Mellark from The Hunger Games (Films) Proposal - November 17 - Status: Approved
- Daring Do, Spike, Rarity, and Zecora from My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Proposal - November 11 - Status: Approved
- Marie, Agent 8, and New Agent 3 from Splatoon Proposal - November 11 - Status: Approved
- Amy Rose from Secret History of Sonic and Tails Proposal - November 5 - Status: Undetermined
- Henry Stickmen from Burdens of a Timeline Traveler Proposal - November 3 - Status: Approved
- Miles "Tails" Prower from Sonic the Hedgehog 2 Proposal - November 2 - Status: Approved
October 2022
- Sasha Waybright from Amphibia Proposal - October 30 - Status: Approved
- Tikki from Miraculous: Tales of Ladybug and Cat Noir Proposal - October 29 - Status: Approved
- Buttercup from The Powerpuff Girls Proposal - October 29 - Status: Approved
- Jimmy Five and Denise from Monica's Gang Proposal - October 29 - Status: Approved
- Old Man McGucket from Gravity Falls Proposal - October 28 - Status: Approved
- Gandalf from Peter Jackson's Middle-earth Film Series Proposal - October 25 - Status: Approved
- Charles Xavier from Wolverine and the X-Men Proposal - October 25 - Status: Approved
- Coraline Jones from the Book and Graphic Novel versions of Coraline Proposal - October 25 - Status: Approved
- Spider-Man from Spider-Man: The Animated Series Proposal - October 25 - Status: Approved
- The Electric Company from The Electric Company (2009) Proposal - October 25 - Status: Approved
- Springtrap from Five Nights at Freddy's: The Stories Proposal - October 24 - Status: Approved
- Billy from Kindergarten Proposal - October 21 - Status: Approved
- Doodlebob and SpongeBob from Doodlebob and the Magic Pencil Proposal - October 21 - Status: Approved
- Minion from Megamind Proposal - October 20 - Status: Approved
- Sally Acorn, Knuckles the Echidna, Cream the Rabbit, and Tails Doll from Sonic.exe: The Spirits of Hell Proposal - October 18 - Status: Approved
- Dr. Zomboss from Absolution Saga Proposal - October 17 - Status: Approved
- Oogway from Kung Fu Panda Reproposal - October 16 - Status: Approved
- Android 21 and Android 16 from Dragon Ball FighterZ Proposal - October 16 - Status: Approved
- General Hubert Galeforce from Henry Stickmen Proposal - October 16 - Status: Approved
- Artemis Fowl II from Artemis Fowl Proposal - October 15 - Status: Approved
- Wedy, Aiber, and Near from Death Note Proposal - October 12 - Status: Approved
- Mordecai and Rigby from Regular Show Reproposal - October 11 - Status: Approved
- Boyfriend from Untold Loneliness Proposal - October 11 - Status: Approved
- Capper, Twilight Sparkle, Sunburst, and Star Twirl from My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Proposal - October 10 - Status: Approved
- Benson Dunwoody from Regular Show Proposal - October 8 - Status: Approved
- Revali from The Legend of Zelda Proposal - October 6 - Status: Approved
- Princess Luna and Celestia from My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Proposal - October 4 - Status: Approved
September 2022
- Jane from The Walking Dead Proposal - September 25 - Status: Rejected
- Damien Darkblood, Cecil Stedman, and Rudolph Conners from Invincible Proposal - September 25 - Status: Approved
- Brown, Grey, Sweet, and Blue from It Ain't Lyin 2 Ambush Yourself Proposal - September 25 - Status: Approved
- Woody from Toy Story Proposal - September 24 - Status: Approved
- Little Wheel from Little Wheel Proposal - September 23 - Status: Approved
- Buck Crosshaw and Witch Hunter from Six Guns Proposal - September 21 - Status: Approved
- Shirley the Medium from Courage the Cowardly Dog Proposal - September 20 - Status: Approved
- Computer from Courage the Cowardly Dog Proposal - September 19 - Status: Approved
- Tails and Eggman from Sonic.exe: The Spirits of Hell Proposal - September 18 - Status: Approved
- Sandy Cheeks from The Bikini Bottom Horror Proposal - September 18 - Status: Approved
- Megatron from Prime Wars Trilogy Proposal - September 18 - Status: Approved
- Debbie Grayson from Invincible Proposal - September 17 - Status: Approved
- Diz from Cancelled Riddle Transfer Proposal - September 14 - Status: Approved
- Oogway from Kung Fu Panda Proposal - September 11 - Status: Rejected
- Catra from She-Ra and the Princesses of Power Proposal - September 11 - Status: Approved
- Tom Cat from That's My Mommy Proposal - September 10 - Status: Approved
- Loki from Warriors Orochi 4 Proposal - September 7 - Status: Approved
- Bugs Bunny from Looney Tunes Proposal - September 7 - Status: Approved
- Courage the Cowardly Dog from Courage the Cowardly Dog Proposal - September 6 - Status: Approved
- Tia from Diamond Jack Proposal - September 5 - Status: Approved
- Yumeko Jabami from Kakegurui Reproposal - September 5 - Status: Approved
- The Chosen One and The Second Coming from Animator vs. Animation Proposal - September 3 - Status: Approved
- Red, Blue, Green, and Yellow from Animator vs. Animation Proposal - September 3 - Status: Approved
- Invincible from Invincible (Comics) Proposal - September 3 - Status: Approved
- Kevin McCallister from Home Alone Proposal - September 2 - Status: Approved
August 2022
- Glamrock Freddy from Five Nights at Freddy's: Security Breach Proposal - August 31 - Status: Approved
- Gaster from Glitchtale Proposal - August 30 - Status: Approved
- Lily from Kindergarten Proposal - August 29 - Status: Approved
- The Puppet from Five Nights at Freddy's Proposal - August 29 - Status: Approved
- Batman from Batman: Dying is Easy Proposal - August 29 - Status: Approved
- Andy Dufresne from Shawshank Redemption Proposal - August 28 - Status: Approved
- Bugs Bunny from Space Jam and Looney Tunes: Back in Action Proposal - August 27 - Status: Approved
- Mike Wazowski from Monsters, Inc. Proposal - August 27 - Status: Approved
- Marina from Splatoon 2 Proposal - August 26 - Status: Approved
- Bucky, Ron, and Zakiel from Bucky and Friends Proposal - August 26 - Status: Approved
- Blossom from The Powerpuff Girls (2016) Proposal - August 25 - Status: Approved
- Sonic the Hedgehog and Knuckles the Echidna from Sonic the Hedgehog Proposal - August 25 - Status: Approved
- Allen from Invincible (Comics) Proposal - August 22 - Status: Approved
- Shinobu Kocho from Demon Slayer Proposal - August 22 - Status: Approved
- Midnight from Monsters Among Humanity Proposal - August 21 - Status: Approved
- D.A. Sinclair from Invincible (Comics) Proposal - August 21 - Status: Approved
- Omni-Man from Invincible (Comics) Proposal - August 21 - Status: Approved
- Sans from Glitchtale Proposal - August 20 - Status: Approved
- Miles "Tails" Prower from Sonic the Hedgehog Proposal - August 19 - Status: Approved
- Sylens from Horizon Proposal - August 17 - Status: Approved
- Giorno Giovanna from JoJo’s Bizarre Adventures: Golden Wind Proposal - August 17 - Status: Approved
- Shintaro Kazama from Yakuza Proposal - August 17 - Status: Approved
- Metro Man from Megamind Removal - August 17 - Status: Approved
- Yumeko Jabami from Kakegurui Proposal - August 17 - Status: Rejected
- Gregory from Five Nights at Freddy's: Security Breach Proposal - August 15 - Status: Approved
- Naomi Misora from Death Note (Anime) Proposal - August 15 - Status: Approved
- Oliver Grayson from Invincible (Comics) Proposal - August 14 - Status: Approved
- Katie Mitchell from The Mitchells vs. The Machines Proposal - August 13 - Status: Approved
- Thaedus from Invincible (Comics) Proposal - August 13 - Status: Approved
- Scoobo from SuperSonicJoseph Proposal - August 13 - Status: Approved
- Kagaya Ubuyashiki from Demon Slayer Proposal - August 12 - Status: Approved
- Bugs Bunny from The Looney Tunes Show Proposal - August 11 - Status: Approved
- Rudolph Conners from Invincible (Comics) Proposal - August 10 - Status: Approved
- Lady Tamayo from Demon Slayer Proposal - August 9 - Status: Approved
- Sunset Shimmer from My Little Pony: Equestria Girls Proposal - August 7 - Status: Approved
- Stanley Pines from Gravity Falls Proposal - August 7 - Status: Approved
- Bubbles from The Powerpuff Girls Proposal - August 7 - Status: Approved
- Metroman from Megamind Proposal - August 5 - Status: Approved
- Megamind from Megamind Proposal - August 5 - Status: Approved
- Felonious Gru from Despicable Me Proposal - August 5 - Status: Approved
- Spider-Man from the Spider-Man Trilogy and the Amazing Spider-Man Script Proposal - August 5 - Status: Approved
- The Knight from Hollow Knight Proposal - August 5 - Status: Approved
- Shadow the Hedgehog from Sonic the Hedgehog Proposal - August 5 - Status: Approved
- Scrooge McDuck and Louie Duck from DuckTales (2017) Proposal - August 2 - Status: Approved
- Sonic the Hedgehog from Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog Proposal - August 2 - Status: Approved
- Rigby from Regular Show Proposal - August 2 - Status: Approved
- Carmen Sandiego from Carmen Sandiego (2019) Proposal - August 1 - Status: Approved
- Tiff from Kirby: Right Back at Ya! Proposal - August 1 - Status: Approved
- Pico from Pico's School Proposal - August 1 - Status: Approved
July 2022
- Phil Eggtree from Riddle School Proposal - July 31 - Status: Approved
- L Lawliet from Death Note Proposal - July 31 - Status: Approved
- Blossom from The Powerpuff Girls Proposal - July 31 - Status: Approved
- Mordecai and Skips from Regular Show Proposal - July 30 - Status: Approved
- TV Game Guy from Angry Video Game Nerd Proposal - July 29 - Status: Approved
- Naoto Shirogane from Persona 4 Proposal - July 27 - Status: Approved
- Nick Wilde from Zootopia Proposal - July 25 - Status: Approved
- Dylan Octarine from Inkopolis Chaos Proposal - July 25 - Status: Approved
- The Mighty Thor from Marvel Cinematic Universe Proposal - July 24 - Status: Approved
- Futaba Sakura from Persona 5 Proposal - July 21 - Status: Approved
- Elliot Ludwig from Poppy Playtime Theories Proposal - July 16 - Status: Approved
- The Time Traveler from HG Wells Connected Universe Proposal - July 16 - Status: Approved
- Medic from Team Fortress 2 Proposal - July 15 - Status: Rejected
- Satoru Fujinuma from Erased Proposal - July 15 - Status: Approved
- Spider-Man from Marvel Comics Proposal - July 14 - Status: Approved
- Bugs Bunny from Learning With Pibby: The Darkness Proposal - July 13 - Status: Approved
- Citron from PvZ Proposal - July 12 - Status: Rejected
- Sans from Undertale Proposal - July 12 - Status: Approved
- Henry Emily from Five Nights at Freddy's Proposal - July 11 - Status: Approved
- Robin Hood from Robin Hood Proposal - July 8 - Status: Approved
- Tracer Bullet from Calvin and Hobbes Proposal - July 8 - Status: Approved
- Hilda from Hilda Proposal - July 8 - Status: Approved
- Mr. Wolf, Mr. Snake, Ms. Tarantula, and Diane Foxington from The Bad Guys Proposal - July 7 - Status: Approved
- Sly Cooper from Sly Cooper Proposal - July 6 - Status: Approved
- Makoto Niijima from Persona 5 Proposal - July 6 - Status: Approved
- Starlight Glimmer from My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Proposal - July 5 - Status: Approved
- Ladybug from Miraculous: Tales of Ladybug and Cat Noir Proposal - July 2 - Status: Approved